Falhas de Governo e a Saúde Pública
Frequentemente se argumenta que o maior envolvimento do governo nos serviços de saúde deve-se às "falhas de mercado". Entretanto, o grande problema do setor são as "falhas de governo", como argumenta John Goodman, expert em economia da saúde:
"I can’t even count the number of articles and blog posts I’ve seen asserting that markets can’t work in health care. Or that they work very imperfectly. Or that they suffer from serious “market failure.” In every case, the writer just assumes that government can remedy these problems.
Yet when Gerry Musgrave and I wrote Patient Power, we concluded that our most serious health care problems stem from bad government policies, rather than from markets failing to work. In other words, “government failure” not “market failure” is the source of most of what is going wrong.
Why is our perspective so different from so many other health policy analysts? I think the answer is: the vast majority of people in health policy do not understand the concept of “government failure.” For example, health economist Austin Frakt, following Nobel Laureate Joe Stiglitz, produced a list of “market failures” in health care and in health insurance at his blog the other day. These include imperfect competition, unequal access to information, external costs and benefits for others generated by private activities, etc. He then offered this observation:
In principle, government intervention can increase that benefit (economic welfare) in such cases. In practice and in some cases, it’s debatable.
How does Austin know that government “in principle” can solve these problems without a model of government decision making? He can’t. Moreover, it turns out that many of the factors alleged to cause “market failure” also contribute to “government failure.” In fact, in the political sphere their impact is much worse. Here is the bottom line: There is no model of government decision making in health care (and in most other areas as well) that shows that government will reliably improve upon the market. (At least a real market.)"
Curioso é que quase sempre que se fala em falhas de mercado comete-se a falácia do nirvana, onde o mundo imperfeito, porém real, é comparado a uma situação idealizada e utópica. O mundo imperfeito sempre perde feio na comparação.- O Mercado Americano De Imóveis
HOUSING AMERICA Building Out of a Crisis Edited by Randall G. Holcombe, Benjamin Powell About seventy percent of American households own their own homes, and for many their homes represent the majority of their net worth. As evident by the cascading...
- Entrevista Com Gary Becker
Em entrevista no WSJ, Gary Becker revela ser "basicamente otimista", no que diz respeito à proteção de liberdades individuais. Alguns excertos da entrevista: I begin with the obvious question. "The health-care legislation? It's a bad bill," Mr....
- Economistas Abandonaram Seus Princípios
É o que dizem Oliver Hart e Luigi Zingales, no WSJ. Para lidar com a crise financeira-econômica, os princípios que devem voltar à cena são: intervir apenas no caso de falha de mercado facilmente identificada e fazê-lo com o menor custo possível...
-
Um texto sobre "tamanho do governo" que me pareceu interessante: Women Prefer Larger Governments: Growth, Structural Transformation and Government Size Tiago V. de V. Cavalcanti† Jos´e Tavares‡ July 2004 Abstract The increase in income...
-
Como o governo engorda em sua luta contra a obesidade Por que a administração Bush não segue uma política menos intrusiva em sua vida pessoal? Esta é uma pergunta que se faz, principalmente quando se pensa no problema da obesidade. Link e trecho:...