The decline of the West is something that has long been prophesied. Symptoms
of decline are all around us today, it seems: slowing growth, crushing debts,
aging populations, anti-social behaviour. But what exactly is amiss with Western
civilization? The answer, Niall Ferguson argues, is that our institutions - the
intricate frameworks within which a society can flourish or fail - are
degenerating.
Representative government, the free market, the rule of law and civil
society: these were once the four pillars of West European and North American
societies. It was these institutions, rather than any geographical or climatic
advantages, that set the West on the path to global dominance after around 1500.
In our time, however, these institutions have deteriorated in disturbing ways.
Our democracies have broken the contract between the generations by heaping
IOUs on our children and grandchildren. Our markets are increasingly distorted
by over-complex regulations that are in fact the disease of which they purport
to be the cure. The rule of law has metamorphosed into the rule of lawyers. And
civil society has degenerated into uncivil society, where we lazily expect all
our problems to be solved by the state.
The Degeneration of the West a powerful - and in places polemical -
indictment of an era of negligence and complacency. While the Arab world
struggles to adopt democracy, and while China struggles to move from economic
liberalization to the rule of law, Europeans and Americans alike are frittering
away the institutional inheritance of centuries. To arrest the degeneration of
the West's once dominant civilization, Ferguson warns, will take heroic
leadership and radical reform.
This book is based on Niall Ferguson's 2012 BBC Reith Lectures, which were
broadcast under the title The Rule of Law and Its Enemies.
By Daniel
Weitz - Published on
Amazon.com
Format:Paperback
This is a review of "The Great Degeneration: How Institutions
Decay and Economies Die" which is the kindle title of this work, and is no
longer available on kindle.
The author is concerned about the
"Degeneration of the West" into a "Stationary State" similar to that of China
during the previous centuries. This he believes is due to the weakening of
traditional civil institutions, crony capitalism, inefficient bureaucracy, and
the decay of our legal system. Needless to say, this has drastic political and
economic consequences for our society, with the widening gap of economic
inequality being a symptom of the problem. Other symptoms are the rise of a
welfare state that exploits those who work for those that have become
"entitled". The abandonment of what Edmund burke called "The partnership between
the generations", is also the abandonment of what is our true social contract.
The excessive public and private debt is a symptom of a deeper problem; the
breakdown of the generational social order.
For the rise of Europe
Ferguson rejects the theories of Diamond (geographic factors), North and Wallace
(transition to open access society), Max Weber (Protestant Capitalism) and
Pomerants ("ghost acres"). The author argues that it is not so much as
geographic and cultural factors (citing the two Koreas and the city of Nogales
on the US-Mexican border), but rather the role of an inclusive elite vs. an
exclusive elite with extractive institutions. He agrees with the argument of De
Soto that dysfunctional institutions force the poor to live outside the law
without title to the property they often "own". This is "dead capital" that
cannot be used to increase wealth.
Ferguson argues that the cause of the
economic meltdown of the banks was not lack of regulation but rather the
inefficiency of the current laws and regulatory system that failed to give jail
time to the miscreants that violated the laws. He also believes that greater
expertise is needed by the regulators rather than strict rules; we need an
experienced pilot with good judgment, not a mandatory auto-pilot that follows
pre-programed rules and cannot adjust to changing conditions in an unknowable
future.
Other chapters deal with the importance of a good legal system
and the need to maintain a civil society. We seem to have done our best to kill
a civil society by replacing it with a cradle to grave government welfare
system, the danger of which was pointed out by the prescient De Tocqueville
almost 200 years ago.
The author's conclusions are troubling, with a
final reference to President Obama, as the "stationary mandarin" (the famous
"you didn't build that" speech) who feels that government institutions and
bureaucracies are the key to growth and not individual initiative supported by a
good legal system, civil institutions, and competition. Other problematic issues
raised is the enormous debt-burden in the West.
A major strength of this
work is the extensive documentation cited in the notes.
- O Que Fazer Na Política Macroeconômica?
John Cochran explica:
Adam Ferguson (Jan 27 Weekly Standard) advice to Janet Yellen is highlighted in “Notable & Quotable” in today’s Wall Street Journal. Ferguson suggests that future Fed Chair Yellen should follow John Cowperthwaite whose...
- Os Fundamentos Do Crescimento Econômico
"A compelling and highly readable book. And [the] conclusion is a cheering one: the authoritarian ‘extractive’ institutions like the ones that drive growth in China today are bound to run out of steam. Without the inclusive institutions that first...
- Crescimento Econômico
Niall Ferguson identifica os seguintes fatores como causas do crescimento econômico, da civilização e do poder do Occidente: concorrência, ciência, direito de propriedade, medicina, sociedade de consumo e ética de trabalho.
Civilization: The West...
-
Para ler nas horas de folga...
Mais um "policy analysis" para minhas horas de folga (se é que elas ainda existem...): Replacing Potemkin Capitalism: Russia's Need for a Free-Market Financial System.
Trecho:
On August 17, 1998, Russia devalued...