Why is Brazil "Underdeveloped"?
John H. Coatsworth
The numbers tell the story (see the table). Brazil is underdeveloped because its economy failed to grow or grew too slowly for most of its history. In the colonial era, sugar, gold and slavery did not create a dynamic economy. In the mid-eighteenth century, Brazil’s economic backwardness worried its Portuguese rulers, but not even the great Pombal, as historian Kenneth Maxwell has shown, could not make good policy substitute for good business. At the time of independence (1822) Brazil had one of the least productive economies in the western hemisphere, with a per capita GDP lower than any other New World colony for which we have estimates.
After independence, while the industrial revolution gather steam elsewhere, imperial Brazil stagnated, growing at a mere 0.2 to 0.3 percent from 1820 to 1870. By the time slavery ended and the empire fell (1888-89), Brazil had a per capita GDP less than half of Mexico’s and only one sixth of the United States. Even when the end of slavery (1888) stimulated massive immigration, the economy failed to grow consistently.
Then came the turn around. From 1913 to 1980, Brazil experienced sustained growth, interrupted only briefly in the early years of the Great Depression, at nearly two percent per year from 1913 to 1950 and nearly four percent from 1950 to 1980. In this period of nearly seven decades, Brazil had the fastest growing economy in the western hemisphere. Per capita GDP increased over eight hundred percent, from $678 in 1900 to $5570 in 2000, measured in 1990 dollars. Brazil’s economy gained on the U.S. economy, rising from only ten percent of US GDP per capita to over 20 percent.
Brazil’s long era of economic growth ended with the crisis of 1982. For the past quarter century, the Brazilian economy has barely grown at all. It has occasionally spurted ahead, as in the past three years, but has fallen back each time it does so. Unfortunately, Brazil cannot turn the clock back and restore the conditions and policies that spurred growth up to 1980.
Why has Brazil grown so slowly for most of its history? Economic historians point to three kinds of answers: geography, institutions and policies.
Leia mais: http://www.drclas.harvard.edu/revista/issues/view/546
- Brasil - Expectativas Não Realizadas
Past and Present: Brazil’s Unfulfilled Expectations Industrial Growth and Structural Change: Brazil in a Long-Run Perspective by Dante Aldrighi ([email protected]) and Renato P. Colistete ([email protected]) Abstract: This paper...
- Dilma Na (própria) Lama
Brazil’s disappointing economy Stuck in the mud Feeble growth has forced a change of course. But the government’s room for manoeuvre is more limited than it was FAILING to meet low expectations is becoming a habit for Brazil’s economy. Figures...
- Crescimento Econômico
Brazil 2012 Growth Forecasts Slashed December 4, 2012 | Filed underBusiness | Posted by Ben Tavener By Ben Tavener, Senior Contributing Reporter SÃO PAULO, BRAZIL – The 2012 growth forecast for the Brazilian economy has been cut for the third consecutive...
- Brasil - Crescimento Econômico Parou
The Brazilian Ego Falters Along With Country’s Economy By Dom Phillips Just a few months ago, Brazil's government dreamed of a 4 percent economic expansion for 2012. With second-quarter statistics in -- GDP grew just 0.4 percent over...
- Conseguirá O Brasil Evitar Sua Argentinização?
Para Sebastian Edwards, o mundo conseguiu evitar a "argentinização" ao longo da crise financeira. A Argentina, ao contrário, continua "argentinizando". Conseguirá o Brasil escapar desta maldição? "But the most important question is what will happen...